A Concerning Trend in Modern Parenting

Tears streaming down a toddler's face spoke volumes – a moment of fear, the need for comfort, and a parent's all-important choice in how to respond. In the warm buzz of a Sunday brunch at a local restaurant, I watched as this universal scene of childhood distress unfolded with a distinctly modern twist. Within seconds, the tears were replaced by the familiar glow of a smartphone screen and a teachable moment of emotional connection dissolved into pixels and animation.

As a psychologist and parent coach, I've spent decades helping families navigate the complex landscape of emotional development. Recently, I witnessed an interaction that exemplifies a concerning trend in modern parenting: using screens as emotional pacifiers.

This past Sunday at brunch, I observed a scene that deeply troubled me as a professional and mom. A toddler, around 18-24 months old, was startled by an unexpected kiss from her grandfather, who appeared out of nowhere. Her natural fear response triggered tears – a completely normal reaction for a child this age. What followed, however, was a textbook example of what we in child psychology call a "missed moment of connection."

Instead of receiving comfort and emotional validation, this little girl's distress was met with indifference from her family members, who continued their adult conversation without acknowledging her feelings. Their solution was a smartphone playing Peppa Pig – a digital band-aid for emotional distress. She stopped crying immediately and entered a trance-like state, eyes glued to the screen, while a critical moment for emotional development slipped away.

The Problems with Digital Distraction

When we substitute screens for emotional comfort, we communicate several problematic messages to our children:

• Your emotions are inconvenient and should be silenced rather than understood

• External stimulation is preferable to internal emotional regulation

• Relationships and human connection are less reliable than digital content and external solutions

• Emotional discomfort should be escaped rather than processed

This approach creates an "emotional regulation deficit" – children never learn to process and manage their emotional experiences properly because they're constantly distracted from them.

The Science of Co-Regulation

Young children's emotional regulation systems are like apprentice electricians – they must work alongside a master to learn the trade. Parents are the external regulators for their children's emotional states, much like a thermostat regulates room temperature. Through consistent, empathetic responses to our children's distress, we teach them how to eventually self-regulate.

When a child experiences fear, as in the case of this toddler, they need several key elements that no screen can provide:

• Physical comfort and safety

• Verbal acknowledgment of their emotional experience

• Help understanding what triggered their response

• Support in returning to a calm state

• Reassurance that their relationships and environment are safe

A Better Response

The scenario I witnessed could have been handled very differently. Imagine if, instead of reaching for the phone, the mother had:

1. Acknowledged her daughter's fear: "Oh, sweetie, that surprise scared you!"

2. Provided physical comfort: picking her up or holding her hand

3. Explained the situation: "Grandpa was so excited to see you, he gave you a surprise kiss, and it startled you."

4. Helped regulate: "Let's take some deep breaths together."

5. Created security: "You're safe here with Mommy, Grandma, and Grandpa, who all love you."

Long-Term Implications

Using screens to manage our children's emotional distress has far-reaching consequences. Children who learn to suppress rather than process emotions often struggle with:

• Difficulty identifying and expressing feelings

• Poor stress management skills

• Increased anxiety and depression

• Dependency on external stimulation for comfort

• Challenges in forming emotional connections with others

Moving Forward

As parents in the digital age, we must resist the temptation to use technology as an emotional shortcut. Screens should never replace our connection and emotional co-regulation with our children. Instead, we should:

• Prioritize face-to-face connections, especially during emotional moments

• Practice active listening and emotional validation

• Model healthy emotional regulation

• Create space for processing feelings, even when it's inconvenient

• Use technology thoughtfully and intentionally, not reactively

Remember, our children's emotional well-being is worth investing our time and attention. Just as we wouldn't give a child learning to swim a life jacket without also teaching them how to swim, we shouldn't give screens to our children's emotions without teaching them how to navigate their emotional waters.

Every emotional moment is an opportunity for connection and learning. When we choose screens over engagement, we're not just missing these opportunities—we're creating patterns that could affect our children's emotional health for years to come.

The next time your child is distressed, pause before reaching for that digital pacifier. Your present, caring response might take more effort, but it's an investment in your child's and your own lifelong emotional well-being and relationship.

____________________________________________________________________________

Dr. Carrie Mackensen ("Dr. Carrie") is a Clinical Psychologist turned Parent Coach with over 25 years of experience. Combining her expertise in child psychology with real-world parenting insights, she helps families navigate the challenges of raising children in the digital age. Through her practice, Successful Parent, she brings brain science down to earth, guiding parents in protecting their children's emotional development while maintaining strong family connections in our screen-focused world. For more info, visit: www.successfulparent.com